Overall Findings
Bluetooth is a wireless networking protocol that allows two devices to communicate with each other through a radio frequency (RF). With Bluetooth, you can wirelessly control a speaker through an app on your phone or to print documents on a printer that isn’t physically connected to your computer. Bluetooth is also used with hands-free headsets, wireless navigation systems, and remote mouse and keyboards. A Wi-Fi network is the wireless extension of a wired modem connection. Wi-Fi is the wireless connectivity protocol used instead of a wired connection such as Ethernet. It requires a wireless router, through which all Wi-Fi devices on the network are channeled. Both Wi-Fi and Bluetooth operate via radio frequency, though the range of a Wi-Fi network is typically larger than a Bluetooth connection. Although many Wi-Fi networks use the same 2.4 GHz band as Bluetooth, Wi-Fi uses more power. Bluetooth 4.0 offers greater speeds than previous versions of the technology. However, it is capped at 25 Mbps, and the effective rate is lower than that. Wi-Fi network speeds vary depending on the protocol, but the slowest tolerable connections are faster than the theoretical limit of Bluetooth 4.0.
Use Cases: Peripherals vs. Whole Home Internet Access
Bluetooth is primarily used to connect two devices over a short range using low energy. This makes it ideal for transmitting audio from a phone or tablet to a speaker system, or for enabling hands-free calls in a car. Bluetooth also provides an easy way to listen to music while driving, functioning as a wireless auxiliary cable. Wi-Fi isn’t used in these situations, as the main purpose is to create a network for other devices to access the internet. Accordingly, it’s more useful in home and office settings than in cars.
Networking: All Route to the Modem
Both wired and wireless devices need to be routed through a modem, which is the actual portal to the internet. As long as the modem is connected to the internet, any device connected to the modem is (or has the capacity to be) connected to the internet. Bluetooth connections can stem from either an Ethernet or Wi-Fi connection. A successful Bluetooth pairing will range up to about 30 feet. However, in most situations, the effective range is shorter. Bluetooth uses comparatively little energy and is fit for a personal area network, or PAN. PANs are used for communication among personal devices and contrast with a LAN. A Wi-Fi network is the LAN through which devices can connect to a modem and, in turn, the internet. For that reason, it’s possible to use a wireless router to establish a Wi-Fi network without any internet connection involved. This allows devices on the network to share data with each other, though these devices won’t be able to connect to the internet without a modem.
Final Verdict
Comparing Wi-Fi and Bluetooth is like comparing apples and oranges. Wi-Fi is superior to Bluetooth in terms of range and speed. Bluetooth is favored for its low energy and narrow RF range, which Wi-Fi lacks. Wi-Fi is the favored standard for establishing wireless home networks. Bluetooth is the favored standard for wirelessly connecting computer peripherals. Bluetooth is also increasingly found in head units, speakers, and home theater receivers. It’s hard to conceive of much competition for either, but the closest would be Wi-Fi Direct. Wi-Fi Direct is a newer take on the device-to-device standard that Bluetooth has dominated for the last couple of decades. Like Bluetooth, Wi-Fi Direct is designed to allow devices to find each other without setting up an ad hoc network. The biggest difference between traditional ad hoc Wi-Fi connections and Wi-Fi Direct is that the latter includes a discovery tool. The other issue with Wi-Fi and Wi-Fi Direct is power consumption, which is heavy and always an issue with mobile devices.
